Page MenuHomePhabricator

Crash when loading .stl Surfaces in ASCII format
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Trying to load a surface saved in .stl ASCII format leads to a crash since MITK-2012.12.

Example file attached.

Event Timeline

Changed hardware flag to linux according to Michaels message.

New remote branch pushed: bug-15743-NewMinorVtkVersion

This is indeed a bug in Vtk version 5.10.0 which was fixed in version 5.10.1.

MITK is being migrated to Vtk 6 at the moment (see T15849) therefore resolving this bug may wait since the migration is completed.

Is there a time schedule for the VTK 6 migration? I think this minor VTK update should not be much work. If the update to 6 will take a while then I suggest we simply do the update.

(In reply to Andreas Fetzer from comment #7)

Is there a time schedule for the VTK 6 migration? I think this minor VTK
update should not be much work. If the update to 6 will take a while then I
suggest we simply do the update.

For all I know the plan is to integrate VTK 6 into the next release. Thus my request for uploading the new VTK 5 version onto mitk.org was rejected.

New remote branch pushed: bug-15743-NewMinorVtkVersion-IntegrationBranch

[572a20]: Merge branch 'bug-15743-NewMinorVtkVersion-IntegrationBranch'

Merged commits:

2013-12-03 07:41:50 Adrian Winterstein [ba0f0b]
Changed cmake message to explicitly mention Vtk version 5.10.0.


2013-12-03 07:38:43 Adrian Winterstein [c27a02]
Classes marked as deprecated.


2013-11-27 14:12:18 Adrian Winterstein [1f7ebd]
Removed unused Vtk widgets.


2013-11-27 13:55:42 Adrian Winterstein [d3a774]
Deactivate QmitkVtkHistogramWidget and QmitkVtkLineProfileWidget for Vtk version greater than 5.10.0.

Necessary because of a bug in Vtk (which will not be fixed).


2013-11-20 14:19:27 Adrian Winterstein [14d1f1]
Merge branch 'bug-15743-NewMinorVtkVersion' into bug-15743-NewMinorVtkVersion-IntegrationBranch


2013-10-30 16:17:12 Adrian Winterstein [d3de50]
New minor VTK version added (VTK 5.10.1).

The bug was fixed in VTK already: http://vtk.org/Bug/view.php?id=13101