Paint function of the Segmentation Bundle is not working well on 2D data. Just try it with the file attached. The painted circle is way too small.
Description
Description
| Status | Assigned | Task | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolved | None | T4017 Allow segmentation on 2D images | ||
| Resolved | None | T3441 Paint function of the Segmentation bundle is not working well on 2D data |
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
Resetting all bugs without active assignee flag to "CONFIRMED". Change status to IN_PROGRESS if you are working on it.
Comment Actions
The output of the GUI is "Segmentation is currently not supported for 2D images.". So I would assume that it was disabled, because of some issues. It is really annoying that we can't draw segmentations on 2D time-of-fligt data...
Comment Actions
Made segmentation of 2D images possible. However, segmentations of 2D images are 3D images with one slice. Huge parts of the segmentation bundle rely on that assumption. We should discuss whether it is really worth it to implement *true* 2D segmentation images.
Comment Actions
Found a feature request concerning this (T4017). Xplanes made a patch which we should examine.
Comment Actions
Discussions are going on to only support 3D(+t) images in the future and to convert 2D(+t) images appropriately and transparent (see T9012).
Comment Actions
Either the paint tool was fixed meanwhile or you are working on zoomed out images. In the latter case you can asure that the diameter of the paint tool cursor is as expected when zooming in.