Page MenuHomePhabricator

Automatic visibility toggle of segmentation bundle is confusing
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Perform the following actions:
-open the segmentation bundle
-load 2 images
-create some segmentations on each image
-try to toggle on/off the visibility of each image/segmentation

It is very confusing!

Event Timeline

There'S a bug in this feature due to the new reference-image comboBox.

[SVN revision 26255]
FIX (#5419): restoring old behaviour of selection of referenceimage in segmentation bundle

[SVN revision 26266]
COMP (#5419): removing Qt::UniqueConnection

removing Qt::UniqueConnection as this seems not be supported by the currently used QT version

Bug still appears in 3M3 v 1.0 installer version

Bug is quite critical. Makes the organ-segmentation via shape models in 3M3 v1.0 quite unusable.

We decided in the last MITK meeting to remove this "feature" in the internal functionality.

Regarding 3M3 we will search for an appropriate solution. => This bug is not 3M3 relevant and nothing will be changed in the current release.

I figured out that the concerning code in "QmitkSegmentationView.cpp" in the method "ForceDisplayPreferencesUponAllImages()". I tried to remove it. Unfortunately, a lot of functions rely on the visible/selected images. Errors and Warnings occur, if you use the bundle this way. Additionally, the tools (or buttons) perform other visibility changes...

Discussion result: 3m3 behavior should remain unchanged. ExtApp and SandboxApp behavior should be configurable.

[SVN revision 27233]
ENH (#5419): When performing an organ segmentation, the resulting
segmentation node was by standard invisible. Now, that node is by
standard visible.

This bug has bee fixed in #5392 -> can be closed