Page MenuHomePhabricator
Projects Request for Discussion

Request for DiscussionTag
ActivePublic
Watch Project

Members

  • This project does not have any members.
  • View All

Watchers

  • This project does not have any watchers.
  • View All

Details

Description

Use this project to tag tasks and other stuff that should be discussed in the weekly MITK meeting.

Recent Activity
View All

Yesterday

kislinsk closed T22328: How to display active labels with multi label segmentations as Wontfix.

Hi there! 馃檪

Tue, May 26, 11:17 AM 路 Auto-closed, MICO (Demo_MICCAI_2017), Request for Discussion, MITK

Mon, May 25

floca claimed T26979: Error when loading a measurement or pointset and then an image.

I know how to fix the obvious problem. But I want to discuss if this is the complete fix or only curing the symptoms,

Mon, May 25, 9:51 PM 路 Request for Discussion, Cleared, MITK (2020)
floca placed T27442: PlanarFigure uses unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry up for grabs.
Mon, May 25, 1:34 PM 路 MITK (2020), Missing Info, Request for Discussion

Sun, May 24

floca closed T27441: PlanarFigure clone is in invalid state due to copy of unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry as Resolved by committing rMITKc46a6fd291ff: Fixed T27441.
Sun, May 24, 8:21 PM 路 Missing Info, Request for Discussion, MITK (2020)
floca lowered the priority of T27442: PlanarFigure uses unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry from Unbreak Now! to Normal.
Sun, May 24, 8:19 PM 路 MITK (2020), Missing Info, Request for Discussion
floca triaged T27442: PlanarFigure uses unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry as Unbreak Now! priority.
Sun, May 24, 8:18 PM 路 MITK (2020), Missing Info, Request for Discussion
floca claimed T27441: PlanarFigure clone is in invalid state due to copy of unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry.
Sun, May 24, 12:02 PM 路 Missing Info, Request for Discussion, MITK (2020)
floca added a comment to T27441: PlanarFigure clone is in invalid state due to copy of unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry.

But we should also discuss if we should have such an unsave construct in the class. I would judge it as premature optimization. The savest way is to over a getter that always casts the BaseData::Geometry to plane geometry and skip the unmanaed member completly. Was there an known issue, explicit plan why the current pattern was chosen?

Sun, May 24, 12:00 PM 路 Missing Info, Request for Discussion, MITK (2020)
floca added a revision to T27441: PlanarFigure clone is in invalid state due to copy of unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry: Restricted Differential Revision.
Sun, May 24, 12:23 AM 路 Missing Info, Request for Discussion, MITK (2020)

Sat, May 23

floca triaged T27441: PlanarFigure clone is in invalid state due to copy of unmanged/uncontrolled pointer for PlaneGeometry as Unbreak Now! priority.
Sat, May 23, 11:45 PM 路 Missing Info, Request for Discussion, MITK (2020)

Fri, May 22

floca moved T27416: DICOM Seg IO skips empty slices when storing DICOM seg from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:04 AM 路 Cleared, HiGHmed, DICOM, MITK (2020)
floca moved T27269: PlanarCircle shrinks in size when moved towards image boundaries from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:04 AM 路 MITK (2020)
floca moved T27270: Planar figures are inconsistently bound by reference image from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:03 AM 路 MITK (2020)
floca moved T27409: Specifiy and implement cleaning policies for MITK tasks from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:03 AM 路 Cleared, Restricted Project, MITK (2020)
floca moved T27435: [Registration] Mapper does not properly support LabelSetImages from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:03 AM 路 MITK (2020)
floca moved T27188: [ImageStatistics] mitkImageStatisticsCalculatorTest fails on some platforms from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:03 AM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020), Restricted Project, CI
floca moved T27266: [Image Statistics] Planar figures cannot be read or written until one of the quantification views is open from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 22, 11:03 AM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020)
floca added a project to T27372: DataNode uses itkCloneMacro(Self) but does not implement a clone method: Request for Discussion.
Fri, May 22, 11:00 AM 路 Cleared, Noteworthy, MITK (2020)

Thu, May 21

floca added a project to T27266: [Image Statistics] Planar figures cannot be read or written until one of the quantification views is open: Request for Discussion.
Thu, May 21, 9:51 PM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020)
floca moved T27435: [Registration] Mapper does not properly support LabelSetImages from Backlog to Registration on the MITK (2020) board.
Thu, May 21, 9:45 PM 路 MITK (2020)

Wed, May 20

floca triaged T27435: [Registration] Mapper does not properly support LabelSetImages as Normal priority.
Wed, May 20, 4:48 PM 路 MITK (2020)
kislinsk moved T27416: DICOM Seg IO skips empty slices when storing DICOM seg from Backlog to DICOM SEG on the MITK (2020) board.
Wed, May 20, 10:35 AM 路 Cleared, HiGHmed, DICOM, MITK (2020)

Wed, May 13

floca triaged T27416: DICOM Seg IO skips empty slices when storing DICOM seg as Normal priority.
Wed, May 13, 10:34 PM 路 Cleared, HiGHmed, DICOM, MITK (2020)
floca updated the task description for T27409: Specifiy and implement cleaning policies for MITK tasks.
Wed, May 13, 12:19 PM 路 Cleared, Restricted Project, MITK (2020)
floca triaged T27409: Specifiy and implement cleaning policies for MITK tasks as Normal priority.
Wed, May 13, 12:18 PM 路 Cleared, Restricted Project, MITK (2020)
kislinsk added a project to T27188: [ImageStatistics] mitkImageStatisticsCalculatorTest fails on some platforms: Missing Info.

We need specific information of the test failures and if they are the same thing.

Wed, May 13, 10:24 AM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020), Restricted Project, CI

Sun, May 10

floca added a project to T25804: Set 'selected' property when using the new selection concept: Request for Discussion.
Sun, May 10, 2:55 PM 路 Request for Discussion, MITK

Fri, May 8

floca moved T27372: DataNode uses itkCloneMacro(Self) but does not implement a clone method from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Fri, May 8, 11:02 AM 路 Cleared, Noteworthy, MITK (2020)
floca lowered the priority of T27269: PlanarCircle shrinks in size when moved towards image boundaries from High to Low.

Curently you can workarround by moving the control point (e,g, for size) to the other side, so that it does not hit the boundary.

Fri, May 8, 10:45 AM 路 MITK (2020)

Thu, May 7

nolden triaged T27383: Update external toolkits as High priority.
Thu, May 7, 4:12 PM 路 Request for Discussion, MITK

Tue, May 5

floca moved T27339: Provide public MITK ModelFit installer on a regular basis from Backlog to Perfusion on the MITK (2020) board.
Tue, May 5, 10:56 AM 路 MITK (2020)

Mon, May 4

floca created T27372: DataNode uses itkCloneMacro(Self) but does not implement a clone method.
Mon, May 4, 8:25 PM 路 Cleared, Noteworthy, MITK (2020)

Thu, Apr 30

nolden raised the priority of T27188: [ImageStatistics] mitkImageStatisticsCalculatorTest fails on some platforms from Normal to High.

Diffusion still shows this:

Thu, Apr 30, 6:57 AM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020), Restricted Project, CI
nolden renamed T27188: [ImageStatistics] mitkImageStatisticsCalculatorTest fails on some platforms from [ImageStatistics] Test failed and is not detected by CTest to [ImageStatistics] mitkImageStatisticsCalculatorTest fails on some platforms.
Thu, Apr 30, 6:56 AM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020), Restricted Project, CI

Apr 27 2020

nolden added a comment to T27001: Rename org.mitk.gui.qt.dicom to org.mitk.gui.qt.dicombrowser.

Strong agree on dicombrowser and avoiding the term editor ...

Apr 27 2020, 10:29 AM 路 MITK (2020), Cleared

Apr 26 2020

floca added a parent task for T26754: Review checklists: Restricted Maniphest Task.
Apr 26 2020, 1:49 PM 路 Request for Discussion, Restricted Project, MITK
floca moved T27001: Rename org.mitk.gui.qt.dicom to org.mitk.gui.qt.dicombrowser from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.

I would use org.mitk.gui.qt.dicombrowser and not *editor. The name does refere to the plugin and not to views, editors, preference pages ... that may be in the plugin.
Second, I think *editor would confuse the people. It is technically the correct term but for the user it implies something that it does not do!

Apr 26 2020, 1:30 PM 路 MITK (2020), Cleared
floca moved T27347: [Registration] Evaluator/Mainpulator new autoselect behavior wanted? from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Apr 26 2020, 1:25 PM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020)

Apr 24 2020

floca moved T27307: Modifying the data does not modify the data node from MITK Meeting to Backlog on the Request for Discussion board.
Apr 24 2020, 5:05 PM 路 Request for Discussion, MITK
floca added a comment to T27307: Modifying the data does not modify the data node.

Interim results of the discussion:

  1. It is a topic
  2. But it is to larga to discuss it in one metting. We should find dedicated slots for discussion or task owner how drives it.
  3. We should focus all design/rework considerations to the central data elements, namely:
    • DataNodes
    • BaseData and derived classes (and maybe agregated sub components)
    • PropertyLists
    • BaseProperty and derived classes
  4. And we should split the discussion between A1 and A2 (divide and conquere). I would start with A2.
  5. Regarding A1, it is also an option to think about which event (bus) mechanism is the best to use. (It must not be the build-in itk option; nevertheless there should be good options to don't use what is already there.)
Apr 24 2020, 5:05 PM 路 Request for Discussion, MITK
floca added a parent task for T27307: Modifying the data does not modify the data node: T22322: Changing a renderer-specific property list of a data node does not modify the data node.
Apr 24 2020, 1:27 PM 路 Request for Discussion, MITK
floca added a parent task for T27305: Inconsistent style for DataNode lists/vectors.: T27354: Make conversion functions for different DataNode lists/vector types publicly available.
Apr 24 2020, 12:15 PM 路 MITK

Apr 23 2020

floca moved T27340: [ModelFit] Request for Mac Workbench installer from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Apr 23 2020, 9:43 AM 路 Request for Discussion, Restricted Project, MITK
floca added a project to T27340: [ModelFit] Request for Mac Workbench installer: Request for Discussion.
Apr 23 2020, 9:43 AM 路 Request for Discussion, Restricted Project, MITK
floca moved T27339: Provide public MITK ModelFit installer on a regular basis from Backlog to MITK Meeting on the Request for Discussion board.
Apr 23 2020, 9:41 AM 路 MITK (2020)

Apr 22 2020

floca moved T27347: [Registration] Evaluator/Mainpulator new autoselect behavior wanted? from Backlog to Registration on the MITK (2020) board.
Apr 22 2020, 10:02 PM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020)
floca created T27347: [Registration] Evaluator/Mainpulator new autoselect behavior wanted? .
Apr 22 2020, 10:02 PM 路 Cleared, MITK (2020)
nolden added a project to T27177: Segmentation based on Multiframe CT can not be saved as DICOM without error message: Request for Discussion.
Apr 22 2020, 10:15 AM 路 Request for Discussion, Restricted Project, MITK
kompan added a comment to T27339: Provide public MITK ModelFit installer on a regular basis.

One reason to integrate modelfit and perfusion into the normal workbench would be that it will probably receive an increased amount of attention via OSIPI over the next two years.

Apr 22 2020, 9:07 AM 路 MITK (2020)

Apr 18 2020

floca added a parent task for T27339: Provide public MITK ModelFit installer on a regular basis: T27340: [ModelFit] Request for Mac Workbench installer.
Apr 18 2020, 4:34 PM 路 MITK (2020)
MITK 路 MIC 路 CAMI 路 DKFZ